迈克尔·摩尔的片子看多了,就不觉得怎样了。但还算好看吧,纪录片比他深的有的是,但像他这么讲故事的,也许没有。
摩尔其实没什么批判分析的能力。他的办法,是给他要批的社会状况找个榜样——瞧瞧人家!讲医疗的那部,是拿欧洲甚至古巴当正面典型。这部呢,是拿美国战后的黄金时代直至里根上台。至于他树立的典型,其内部的复杂状况和弊病,他是不管的。
摩尔出身工人家庭,臃肿的外形绝对蓝领,但他是蓝领以及美国劳动人民的代表吗?我怀疑。
没有真正的批判能力,最终不过是和资本主义成为一对欢喜冤家。看到摩尔把希望寄托在奥巴马身上,更上溯到罗斯福时代,搬出宪法第二修正案,不免有啼笑皆非之感。
资本和民主有很多张脸孔,懂得资本主义的人和他调调情就算,可偏偏有很多人真心爱他,那就杯具了。
资本主义也很会和反对他、想踹他两脚的人调情,比如摩尔。
最终,真不知道是谁玩弄了谁。游戏还在继续。
As is described in the "Second Bill of Rights" by Roosevelt, we people ought be own:
the right of a descent job,
the right of an adequate and deserved wage,
the right of the general health care
the right of a house
the right of the education
the right of the pension
and, maybe of course, like the right of a 4-week paid holiday.
that's what the middle class wants. and these are the people who are the most descent, cultivated, affectionate, philanthropic, willing to do charity ones. According to morality system, to religion and belief, to the wise words of our ancient greatest souls, these people bears the most advanced and civilized merits, thereby, logically should be leading our society.
I do believe in what老农 said, the essence of American spirit is American dream, and the core of American dream is to live on our born talents and afterborn efforts. Thus I do believe that the best, the most suitable style for America is Republican party's way of running the government.But is this also a fantasy created on the basis of Utopia? And is Republican America , the dreaming Capitalidsm also an ideal while imconstructable fantasy just like Communism?
Actually the movie can suit any country else, even including China.
这个阴谋论拍滴有点蠢,michael moore是一个典型的思路混乱,又喜欢哗众取宠滴美国佬。话说我虽不偏向拥有话语权的权贵,但是一直认为对于穷人,尤其是那些只会抱怨为富不仁,整天期盼着免费午餐的穷人,也没什么好同情的,话说可怜之人必有可恨之处。。。
只不过在中国,情况又不一样。中国国民素质低下的根本不是穷人,而是那帮自恃为精英,占有着社会资源却又不履行相应社会责任的黑领们。。。哎哟,开始愤青了。。。
什么是聪明的阴谋论,可以去看一下Zeitgeist,绝对会带来一个paradigm shift.
“资本主义:一个爱情故事”出品精良!这导演是个准纳粹分子
转载请注明网址: https://www.dingshenggs.cn/products/11588.html